Top K Query Processing, or FULL SCAN IS THE DEVIL! avoid it


Almost always, users wouldn’t want to see all the results coming back from query. The query result set is usually restricted by conditions and first (or first few) page(s) of response is all user wants to see. If you ask me to describe db optimization in a sentence, I would say the sentence is: avoid full table/index scans. This is the single key to highly performing db applications. However, avoiding full scans is not trivial at all. In fact, it is a hard problem. If your table has n records, full table scan has complexity of O(n). A join between two tables with full scans will have the complexity of O(n^2) and so on. It can get out of control pretty easily.
Have you been in a situation that a tiny 10GB database with just a few million records takes 10 minutes to respond to a query?
Ever wondered how google returns search results from its super massive tables for millions of user on eack keystroke? No matter how expensive your hardware is and how much processing power you have, your machine will be on its knees when a complex query full scans massive tables for a bunch of queries. You have to know your data very well, and you have to know your users (or use cases) very well. Do whatever to avoid full scans on large data sets specially if the query is run frequently. Obviously there is no problem to run a query that takes 5 minutes once every weekend but never a frequently used query should take more that a few seconds. There are heaps you can do to avoid full scans and it is well covered under query processing resources. Read this book to learn some techniques to do such stuff in Ms Sql Server 2008.

Despite all the powerfull tools and smartness that SQL Server or any other commercial DBMS provides, there are cases that top k query processing is not possible at all with just writing SQL. That is when you need to know about the algorithms. Yes! some computer science fun! Top k query processing is a widely studied subject, and there are heaps of methods and techniques that can super drastrically improve the application performance! Unfortunately most comercial DBMSs do not support even easiest top k query processing techniques and algorithms. Hence, you have to code them yourself if you decided to use them. A few top k query processing techniques like TA and PRA are quiet quick and easy to develop but some others are harder and much more complex. This 2008 Acm Survey is an excellent source to gain good understanding of top k query processing thanks to the guys at Waterloo university, ON, Canada.

To be precise. my message on this post is that there is no excuse for long running queries!

Advertisement

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: